The judges said she's showing masses of personality but somehow I thought she could've been more theatrical and had more fun. Good job on interacting with the musicians though

Disaster all round! He looks stoned all the way. He doesn't even know it's from Cats? Oh go back to your hippie surfer dude world. I love Andrew Lloyd Webber's comments though. And that British accent too. He's just so spot on with all the contestants.

Brooke sounded good but somehow I was bored. Why was the audience dead silent during the comments. And Paula looked like she fell asleep.

Props to David for taking a risk and incorporating his 'Stevie runs' into the song (though it became rather unrecognisable in the middle). It really sounds like him, but unfortunately I get rather bored with his voice. Again, it's a good one and it shows he's a talented composer (or rearranger?) but it just doesn't interest me as much as the other David's. And quit it with the adoring teenyboppers already. Sheesh! Ryan always seeks to embarrass him.


Carly Smithson- Jesus Christ Superstar

Shouty shouty shouty. What's with the outfit anyway? Thought she wanted a cool dress. Ricky Minor dancing is cool! And Randy's fashion sense has gone to the dawgs.

This song really showcased how strong his vocals are. As much as I liked Always Be My Baby last week, I didn't like it when he swallowed words and went into some rocker style mumbling into the mike. This week everything was clear and absolutely wonderful. I'm glad he kept to the original composition and didn't change anything (except for the last note which didn't end very well for me)

Paula: You have a beautiful instrument there. ooh

I don't get it with Simon, you want versatility or not? Prefer people in this genre or that. Ryan, no no don't sing.